Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers: Features and Trade-offs

For most home drinkers, the OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker suits anyone who wants clean, low-mess concentrate, the Toddy system suits people who brew big batches and keep them for days, and the Hario Mizudashi or Takeya pitchers suit anyone who wants a slim, inexpensive, ready-to-drink brew that fits a fridge door. Which one is right depends on how much you drink, how much fridge space you have, and how much cleanup you will tolerate.

Our top picks

Top pickQHH Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Check price on Amazon

Also greatCounty Line Kitchen 64oz Cold Brew Coffee

Check price on Amazon

Also great64 oz Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Check price on Amazon

Also greatTakeya Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Check price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Cold Brew Makers at a Glance

How Cold Brew Systems Differ

Every cold brew maker does the same basic job. Coarse-ground coffee steeps in cool or room-temperature water for many hours, then the grounds are separated from the liquid. The differences lie in how that separation happens and in what comes out. Makers that produce concentrate use a bigger dose of coffee relative to water, and you dilute the result with water, milk, or ice when you pour. Makers that produce ready-to-drink coffee use a lower coffee-to-water ratio, and you pour straight from the pitcher.

Filtration style matters for taste and cleanup. A paper or felt filter catches more fine particles and gives a cleaner cup, while a metal mesh lets through more oils and fine grit, which many drinkers describe as a fuller body. Reviewers across several outlets generally describe felt-filtered systems as the smoothest and mesh pitchers as the simplest to rinse out.

Capacity is the other big variable. A concentrate system can turn one batch of grounds into many servings because each serving is diluted, so a modest container still yields a week of drinks. A pitcher gives you roughly what it holds, so a household that drinks several glasses a day will be brewing again every couple of days. Think about your real consumption before you choose, because running out is the most common frustration with small pitchers.

OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker

The OXO is the system most often named best overall in recent roundups, including a list from Forbes Vetted, largely because it removes the messiest step. Grounds sit in a mesh basket, water is poured through a distributing top so it wets them evenly, and after the brew time a switch on the base releases the concentrate into a separate carafe. The grounds are never poured through anything, which keeps counters and sinks cleaner.

Reviewers cite smooth flavor and tidy handling as the main reasons to choose it. The trade-offs are practical. It has more components than a simple pitcher, so there is more to wash, and the tall brewing column plus carafe takes up space. Because it makes concentrate, you will also need to settle on your own dilution ratio. Check the maker’s instruction sheet for the recommended amount of grounds, water volume, and steep time rather than guessing, and use the coarse grind it calls for.

Best for: people who drink cold brew daily, want repeatable results, and would rather pay more for convenience. Skip it if fridge space is tight.

Toddy Cold Brew System

Toddy is among the best-known names in home cold brew and is the pick several outlets give for big batches. The design is an immersion brewer. You combine grounds and water in the brew container, let it steep, then pull the stopper so the concentrate drains through a felt filter into a glass decanter. The maker states the concentrate stays good for up to two weeks in the refrigerator, which makes it practical to brew once and drink for many days.

Reviewers like the clean, smooth cup and the long storage window. The downsides are the filter and the process. Felt filters are reusable but wear out and need to be replaced on the maker’s schedule, and they should be rinsed well and stored as the manual describes so they do not hold on to old coffee smells. The drain step takes a little care to avoid drips.

Best for: households that go through a lot of iced coffee, small offices, and anyone who wants concentrate on hand for iced lattes, coffee cocktails, or desserts. It is also a good fit if you like the idea of one large weekly brew.

Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Pitcher

The Hario Mizudashi is a slim glass pitcher with a mesh filter basket in the neck and a lid that seals. It is ready-to-drink: add coffee grounds and cold water, steep it in the fridge, remove the filter, and pour. It is widely listed as a leading compact or budget choice, and the narrow shape slides into a refrigerator door shelf.

Compared with the felt-filtered Toddy, reviewers say the mesh basket lets slightly more fine sediment through, which gives a little more body. Glass construction is easy to inspect and does not hold odors, but it is breakable and should be handled and washed carefully. Capacity is modest compared with concentrate systems, so heavy drinkers will brew more often.

Best for: one or two people, small kitchens, and anyone trying cold brew for the first time without a large commitment.

Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew Coffee Maker

Takeya sells brew-and-store pitchers with a fine-mesh infuser and an airtight lid. The maker positions them as a way to brew, chill, and pour from one container. Roundups such as Forbes name it a strong value pick, while one independent blind comparison rated its smoothness below that of the OXO, so expect a slightly lighter, less polished cup. Check the specific pitcher you are buying for material (plastic or glass) and capacity, because Takeya sells several versions.

Best for: people who want a lower-cost, portable pitcher, who will brew regularly, and who will not mind the lighter body that mesh infusers can give.

Budget Tiers

• Budget: Hario Mizudashi and Takeya pitchers. Simple, few parts, small batches, mesh filtration.
• Mid-range: Toddy and OXO. Concentrate, larger yield per batch, better filtration or cleaner handling, but more parts and more storage space.
• Premium: Countertop electric or keg-style cold brew machines. These sit outside the pitcher category and suit cafes or serious enthusiasts who want faster or larger-volume brewing.

Pick X If… Decision Table

Size, Fit and Care Notes

• Fridge fit: Measure shelf height before buying a tall carafe or pitcher. Slim pitchers fit in a door; concentrate systems usually need a shelf.
• Grind: Makers consistently call for coarse grounds. Fine grounds clog filters and make bitter, muddy coffee.
• Food safety: Keep cold brew refrigerated while steeping and storing, wash all parts between batches, and follow the maker’s storage window. Discard coffee that smells or tastes off.
• Cleaning: Check whether parts are dishwasher-safe in the manual; felt filters usually are not.
• Material: Glass is easy to keep clean but fragile. Plastic is lighter and more portable but can pick up odors over time.

Alternatives to a Dedicated Cold Brew Maker

• French press: Steep coarse grounds in water in the fridge, press, and pour through a paper filter if you want a cleaner cup.
• Mason jar with a filter bag: Cheap and flexible, but you manage the filtering and cleanup yourself.
• Electric cold brew machines: Countertop appliances that speed up steeping with agitation or recirculation. They cost more, so read the maker’s specs on batch size and cleaning before choosing one.

Using Cold Brew in Drinks

Concentrate is flexible beyond the glass of iced coffee. Diluted one to one with cold water it makes a standard serving, and stronger pours work as a base for iced lattes, coffee tonics, or coffee-forward cocktails such as an espresso martini variation. If you plan to mix drinks, a concentrate system like the Toddy or OXO gives you more control over strength, while a ready-to-drink pitcher is better when you simply want a glass over ice. For any alcoholic recipe, measure carefully and drink responsibly.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should cold brew steep?

Each maker publishes its own recommended steep time, and most fall in the range of about 12 to 24 hours. Shorter steeps taste lighter and more acidic, while very long steeps can taste bitter or flat. Follow the instructions that came with your brewer, then adjust by an hour or two to your taste.

Is concentrate better than ready-to-drink?

Neither is better in absolute terms. Concentrate stores more coffee in less space and lets you tune strength with each pour, while ready-to-drink pitchers are simpler and take less planning. If you drink two or more glasses a day, concentrate is usually more convenient.

What grind size works best?

Makers and reviewers point to a coarse grind, similar to what you would use for a French press. A coarse grind slows extraction, keeps the cup smooth, and prevents fine grit from clogging the filter. Ask your roaster or grocery grinder for a coarse setting if you do not grind at home.

How long does cold brew keep in the fridge?

It depends on the system. Toddy states its concentrate keeps up to two weeks refrigerated, while ready-to-drink pitchers generally have shorter windows, often around a week. Always check the instruction sheet, keep it covered and cold, and throw it out if it smells sour.

Can I use any coffee beans?

Yes, any roast works, and the choice is a matter of taste. Medium and dark roasts tend to give chocolatey, mellow flavors, while light roasts can taste fruity but may seem thin. Fresh beans ground just before brewing usually taste best.

Is cold brew less acidic than hot coffee?

Many drinkers find it tastes smoother and less sharp. Whether it is easier on a sensitive stomach varies from person to person, and it is not guaranteed. If coffee causes you discomfort, talk to a doctor rather than relying on a brewing method.